Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

0 Comments

  1. This list seems brief. Although I own MANY of the commentaries listed here there are other contributing factors that should help define the list. There are some “single volume” commentaries that are beneficial for someone who needs less depth and wants to spend less money–they are theologically sound and have at least a few paragraphs about nearly every book in the bible. You should also note that ALL of these commentaries would be considered “conservative evangelical” in their nature and theology (it is not a bad thing–I fall into that large tent myself–but it’s best not to assume).

    It may be helpful to consider several factors when thinking about commentaries:
    (1) level of education–you list many in the NIGNT series, which is a GREAT series, but not worth it if you do not possess a working knowledge of Greek (same is true with some in the WBC series)–it is unfair to assume that everyone wanting to use a commentary has that ability (though I hope they do).

    (2) Different series and commentaries are meant for different things. For instance the “The Bible Speaks Today” series and the “Interpretation” series are both good series but are more devotional in nature and you won’t find the depth of hermeneutics, or interpretive and theological “struggling” that go on in volumes that aim at a deeper audience. Some are great “middle-of-the-road” works (NIV Application, IVP, Tyndale, etc…) and offer something for everyone–one should know what they are seeking AND what they are getting into before they fork over hard earned money.

    (3) Not every volume of every series is helpful…after thirty years in ministry I NEVER steer young people towards buying an entire set–most are just not worth it. If you are like me you probably have a “pool” to draw from. That doesn’t mean that the pool can’t expand–but after awhile you find authors that you trust–and they become your pool–regardless of what publishing house they are working with/for.

    (4) Theological bias—we ALL have it–be aware of it. Sometimes it is a help and sometimes it is a hindrance and the same is true with those writing, selling, and buying commentaries.

    (5) Network–I commend you for your blog and for your list–everyone needs someplace to start. Ask others who they recommend–to often these days students, teachers, preachers, etc…put their trust in the Amazon comment or rating system rather than talking to people they actually know who might have used these volumes–I know everyone is busy–but ask them if they have time to jot down their honest assessment and reflection on the volume(s) you are interested in (which it seems to me that you have tried to do here…so THANKS…again).

    1. Thanks for the added pointers. I agree that I probably could have been more clear between distinguishing the more technical from devotional commentaries. And yes, I too am theologically conservative, so I hope the list reflects that. My intention was to put out a list of some of the top recommended commentaries I originally compiled for myself based on feedback from seminary professors, pastors, and top experts over the years. But I sincerely appreciate the extra tips for everyone who reads the list. Thanks.

  2. Thanks for this great list. Just two comments. (1) There are commentaries which are already available in a revised version. Carsons commentary on Matthew ist one of them, another one is Fees Commentary on 1 Corinthians. I know, a revision is not automatically better, but I think in those cases it is. At least I read large portions of Carsons revised Commentary. (2) There is not a single volume of the ZECNT commentaries listet. Personally this is my favorite series, but at least some of them are clearly superb. I would number Schnabel on Acts, Osborne on Matthew and Schreiner on Galatians among them. If you haven’t you should check them out.

  3. Hey Brandon,

    I just wanted to let you know that this list was extremely helpful to me. The Lord definitely used this as an answered prayer as I have been looking for a “curated” list if you will of the best commentaries for the money. It is very encouraging to see that my Bible College has most if not all of these books in their library. I cannot wait to immerse myself in the word of God much further than I already have and I fully expect these resources be a source of great wisdom!

    Thank you truly for the work you have put into compiling these commentaries. It was certainly a blessing.

    In Christ,

    -Matt

  4. This is an answer prayer. Thank you so much for taking our time to do this research to help other. May Our Lord continue to bless you.

  5. Well, it is worth it, is what I need to hear! I am 68 yrs old and want feedbackand a some advice about being a pastor. I’ve had a up and down kind of life, but has taught me valuable lessons i needed! Oh, am a female in good health so far by God’s grace and much prayer.
    Thank you for your honesty.
    J.